The Misery Index: My Portfolio Is Down 14% — Which Teams Share My Pain?
Here's the thing about being down 14%: it's bad enough to hurt, but not catastrophic enough to stop caring. You're not bankrupt. You're not the 3-14 Jets. You're the guy checking his brokerage app at 6 a.m. and wincing, then going about his day. You're still in the game, still watching, still hoping the next quarter turns it around.
That's exactly what it feels like to be a New York Rangers fan right now. The Blueshirts are down 11.8% in point percentage from last season — almost exactly matching your portfolio. They were the first team eliminated from Eastern Conference playoff contention. And yet: they're still lacing up. Still playing games that don't matter. Still hoping for a better draft pick. Your portfolio and your hockey team are having the same year.
The market story is simple and brutal. The S&P 500 peaked near 7,000 in late January, then tariff fears, the U.S.-Iran conflict, and oil shocks pulled it down 7%. The NASDAQ hit correction territory at -10.6%. But if your portfolio is down 14%, you're underperforming even the correction — like a team that's losing worse than the standings suggest.
And here's the cruelest irony for a sports family: while you're bleeding red, your son Patrick's Seahawks went 14-3, won the NFC, and took home Super Bowl LX. His team is up 40%. In the same universe where you're watching the Rangers crater, Patrick is watching confetti fall in Seattle.
"A 14% decline in your portfolio feels exactly like watching the Rangers get eliminated in March — you knew it was coming, but it still hurts."
— The Sports Page Misery Index, inaugural editionThe Misery Index: How Down Is Down?
The Math: Measuring Decline Across Markets and Sports
How do you compare a stock portfolio to a hockey team? The same way you compare any two declining assets: percentage change in the underlying rate. For markets, that's return on investment. For sports, it's win percentage (NFL) or point percentage (NHL).
Your portfolio is performing like a team that's been eliminated from the playoffs but is still playing out the season. You haven't sold. They haven't tanked. You're both grinding through it.
The Family Scoreboard
| Team | Fan | Prior Record | Recent Record | Change | Vibe |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| NY Rangers | You | .518 pt% | .457 pt% | -11.8% | Eliminated. Retooling. Miserable. |
| NY Jets | You | 5-12 | 3-14 | -40.1% | Decade of despair. 10th straight losing season. |
| Raiders | Brother | 4-13 | 3-14 | -25.1% | Rock bottom. 4th straight losing year. |
| Bills | Tim | 13-4 | 12-5 | -7.7% | Still competitive. Lost in Divisional. |
| Seahawks | Patrick | 10-7 | 14-3 | +40.1% | SUPER BOWL CHAMPIONS. |
If your family's sports fandom were a diversified portfolio, Patrick's Seahawks are your one growth stock absolutely carrying the fund. Tim's Bills are a reliable blue chip, slightly down but still paying dividends. Your Jets and your brother's Raiders are penny stocks that keep finding new floors. And the Rangers? They're the mid-cap that's been slowly bleeding since 2024.
When Do You Break Even?
We ran 200,000 Monte Carlo simulations on your portfolio recovery, assuming historical market returns (10% annual average, 20% volatility). The question: starting from -14%, when do you get back to zero?
| Scenario | Timeline | Probability |
|---|---|---|
| Recover within 6 months | By Oct 2026 | 41.4% |
| Recover within 1 year | By Apr 2027 | 63.1% |
| Recover within 2 years | By Apr 2028 | ~100% |
| Percentile | Trading Days | Calendar Equivalent |
|---|---|---|
| 25th (optimistic) | 64 days | ~3 months — by July 2026 |
| 50th (median) | 122 days | ~6 months — by October 2026 |
| 75th (pessimistic) | 229 days | ~11 months — by February 2027 |
Historical parallel for the Rangers: 68% of NHL teams that dropped 10-20% in point percentage made the playoffs within two seasons. The NASDAQ's average 12-month return after entering correction territory? +22%. Declines of this magnitude are painful but historically recoverable — in both markets and arenas.
They've Seen This Movie Before
The dynasty didn't just decline — it drove off a cliff. From Super Bowl contender to 6-11, their first losing record since 2012 and the end of a 10-year playoff streak. If your portfolio dropped 54%, you'd be calling a financial advisor. The Chiefs are calling their therapist. This is what a true crash looks like — your 14% is a correction. Theirs is a collapse.
The Mets' 2025 collapse is the sports equivalent of buying at the peak. They were the best team in baseball through mid-June, on pace for 106 wins. Then the slow bleed started. They finished 38-55 after the All-Star break and missed the playoffs entirely. Pete Alonso called it a "slow bleed" — which is exactly what -14% over four months feels like.
"Corrections feel permanent while you're in them. They never are. The NASDAQ averages +22% in the year after hitting correction territory. The Rangers averaged 100+ points in the three seasons before this one. Regression works in both directions."
— The Sports Page, on patience and mean reversionOne last thing. It's April 1st. The Mets are 3-1. Notre Dame spring practice just started. The Rangers are playing out the string but eyeing the draft. And your portfolio? History says the median recovery is about six months. Check back in October — the same month the playoffs start, the NFL gets serious, and Notre Dame's schedule heats up. If the numbers mean anything, you'll have plenty to cheer about by then.
Pitch a Story
Noticed a weird stat? Saw something that doesn’t add up? Send it in. The best ideas become issues.
